1 Traumdetung, by Prof. Dr. Sigmund Freud. Authorized English translation (The Interpretation of Dreams) of 3rd edition by Dr. A. A. Brill. London, George Allen & Unwin, Ltd.; New York, The Macmillan Company. This is a rather difficult volume, especially for beginners. Those interested in Freud's theories will find a popular exposition of his views on dreams in The Meaning of Dreams, by Dr. Isador H. Coriat. Boston, Little, Brown & Co. Man's Unconscious Conflict, by Wilfrid Lay, Ph.D., is a popular discussion of Freud's theories in "general. Kew York, Dodd, Mead & Co.

A certain amount of elaboration takes place unconsciously (primary elaboration), but secondary elaboration is wholly a matter of early waking thought; simply, it is an effort of the dreamer to alter the dream to suit himself. Throughout these processes the endopsychic censor has been active. This is the inhibitory influence of consciousness which will not permit unacceptable ideas, which seek admittance, to come to consciousness. There results a psychic struggle between the ideas - desires - and the censor, resulting in a compromise, whereby the thoughts are allowed to enter but disguised by symbolisms, and other distortions. The dream as remembered has, therefore, an entirely different meaning from the thoughts which have produced it; and to have a knowledge of the meaning an extensive analysis of the dream is usually necessary.

Freud's conceptions as to the mechanisms of dreams is, to say the least, novel and interesting. Doubtless, his theories would be more generally acceptable were it not for his attempt to trace practically all dreams to infantile and childhood complexes, and because he sees hidden in every dream a wish fulfilment. The term wish fulfilment is used broadly to include all unsatisfied yearnings, cravings, hopes, desires, which, by reason of their conflict with the individual's ethical standards have been repressed from consciousness.

If the conception that dreams fulfilled all wishes such as may be entertained by an individual were the Freudian contention, then we might be able to agree with him more. All our daily thoughts and acts are, in the last analysis, offsprings of wishes, and seek the fulfilment of wishes. We repair our automobiles so that they will run smoothly and thus promote our comfort; we read a book to pass a few hours more pleasurably, or for the knowledge we may obtain from it; we perform our daily work because we like occupation or because we seek the remuneration that goes with it; we think of various problems seeking their solution; we day-dream because we find it promotes pleasure. Even our fears, by night or by day, are prompted by the wish for self-preservation. However, we find that our daily acts and thoughts, though seeking, consciously or unconsciously, the gratification of wishes are many sided.

It is true that when awake we can direct our thoughts; we can, also, usually keep from consciousness those thoughts which disturb our peace of mind. It is true, too, that dreams proceed involuntarily; that we control them little or none; that in sleep the power to repress thoughts is slack, and that there must be a mass of thoughts available for dream life which have been repressed by reason of their unacceptability to conscious-ness. However, it does not seem logical that our night thoughts should be entirely one sided, seeking solely the gratification of repressed wishes, particularly those related to the love life of an individual, as Freud contends. Surely there are many other interests which are quite as important, and with which the dream deals. We might refer to day-dreams, which are involuntary and which are closely related to night-dreams. While day-dreams are chiefly wish fulfilments, it is easily seen that they are concerned with many and varied wishes, though, like night-dreams, they, too, may have a sexual make-up.

Of course there are some instances where the Freudian views can be proved true, but it is questionable if we are justified always in inferring that all the associations which the dream as remembered gives rise to are true indicators of the thoughts which have made the dream. Any thought, persistently carried through associative processes, will eventually bring to mind something sexual. Our thoughts and acts are founded on past experiences ; something like a house is made up of bricks, boards, nails, mortar, and other material with which the builder is acquainted. If we "analyse" a house and discover a bad board, for instance, this does not indicate that the house is entirely bad, nor that the house was made to hide this bad board. Similarly, if in the analysis of thoughts, night or day, a portion is found to be defective morally, this is no indication, per se, that the other associations were fashioned merely as a disguise for the thought.

There are several other objections to the acceptation of Freud's views in toto. For instance, it is difficult to conceive that the dream's symbolism is one-sided, that nervous disorders are so much dependent upon repressed, unethical material. Moreover, as one reads the various analyses put out by followers of Freud, he would think that scarcely a poem, a myth, a work of literature, piece of art, or any human endeavour could not be traced to repressed fantasies. Of course, we cannot censure Freud for whatever some of his rabid exponents may do, yet the writings of these show us the direction in which the minds of those who believe his theories implicitly are apt to run.

Whether we believe in Freud's views or not, we are forced to admit that he has added very materially to psychological knowledge. His theories are applicable in many cases; he has emphasized the harmfulness of repression; his method of mental exploration is often useful in discovering buried mental complexes; he has placed the study of the dream on a scientific basis. Naturally, he has a number of followers, some of whom are prominent psychopathologists, and who accept his theories without question; others accept his views partly; the latter Freud would probably divorce from his school of psycho-analysts, just as he has expelled, apparently, Jung, of Zurich, and Adler, of Vienna, two former adherents. There are other psychologists who see practically nothing but error in Freud's tenets. For example, Dr. Dercum1 of Philadelphia. This writer considers that dreams arise just as the sleeper is awaking, or in periods of light sleep; and that they have their origin in apparently vague sensory impressions from without or within the body. Their arrangement into order occurs after awaking. As far as the methods of the psycho-analysts are concerned, Dercum believes that dreams can be made to yield anything the analyst is looking for.