This section is from the book "The Psychology Of Dreams", by William S. Walsh. Also available from Amazon: The Psychology of Dreams.
As will be noted, dreams predicting physical illness are portrayed in symbolic form. Symbolism is used because this is the language of dreams. The sleeping consciousness attempts to explain the stimulus reaching it from the body, and creates an image as much in accord with the intensity of the stimulus, and the general associations to which it gives rise in memory, as is possible for sleeping consciousness with the reasoning at its disposal. Thus, a beginning ulcer, boil, or other growth causes a piercing sensation which is magnified by sleeping consciousness and interpreted as the bite of a serpent, a mouse, cutting by sharp instruments, etc. The labouring heart is symbolized by panting, sweating horses. The interpretation depends not only upon the intensity of the stimulus but upon the individual himself. We do not all interpret stimuli alike even in the waking state; again, we are likely to create an image in accord with our individual experiences and reasoning powers.
It will also be noted that the trouble appears to reside outside the body in many cases. As before explained, sleeping consciousness acts very much like waking consciousness in referring difficulties arising within to outside sources. Still another reason is that when the difficulty appears to come from without it is more easily eliminated. If sleeping consciousness felt that the trouble was within, as in the heart, anxiety and awakening might be caused; since it seems to exist as a result of escapable causes, less anxiety, if any, results. We may, therefore, consider that the symbolism is made use of for the purpose of conserving sleep.
In studying prodromic dreams the possibility of the individual's having had a transient thought that some ill might be befalling him, which thought was dismissed promptly and forgotten, must be borne in mind. For instance, a vague discomfort in the region of the leg might prompt a fleeting thought that an ulcer was there. The thought might then become unconscious, and give rise to a dream, as transient thoughts often do. Moreover, a recurrent dream might ensue. However, unless the thought was based on well-founded anxiety no disease would result, save, possibly, an hysterical one.
While some prodromic dreams may occur in a typical manner to many persons, as the dream of sweating horses in heart disease, we cannot agree with the older writers, as Aristotle, that to definite diseases correspond definite dreams. According to Chaucer, "The dominating humour makes the dream." Moreover, a person who consults the popular dream book in this connection is apt to worry needlessly. The lesson to be learned from what has been discussed is that dreams are sometimes truly prophetic as far as a physical illness is concerned. To an occasional dream of biting, clawing, etc., attention need not be paid. The dream is important only when it, occurs frequently and in practically the same form. Considering that stimuli from the body frequently enter into the dream thoughts, the constant presence of a certain animal, or person in the dream, even though the dream varies markedly, may be significant. While the dream may have no connection whatsoever with a physical trouble, it is only prudent to consult a physician when it occurs often. The same advice applies to those who have unhappy dreams often. In some cases unhappy dreams are due to physical errors; in others to mental problems or anxieties which require medical treatment.
The dreams that have been described must be separated from those followed by an illness purely hysterical in nature. Dreams followed by loss of sight, hearing, paralysis have been mentioned in another place. These occur chiefly in nervous persons, or those of a very impressionable make-up. All told, the number of true prodromic dreams is small, so that it may be best, particularly for nervous persons, to look upon the subject as of theoretical rather than practical interest.
While there is truth in prodromic dreams there is little or none in dreams which are said to indicate the measures by which an existing disease may be cured. It is possible, of course, that in a dream a valuable suggestion may be received, but there is nothing of a di-vinatory power in this.
We have many examples of diseases apparently cured through suggestions given in dreams. Galen is said to have had an inflammation of the diaphragm, and to have been instructed in a dream to open the vein most apparent between thumb and forefinger. He did so and was cured. Pliny, in his Natural History, tells us that Alexander was sleeping by his friend Ptolemaus who was dying of a poisoned wound. In his dream a dragon appeared, holding a certain plant in its mouth, and saying that the plant would cure Ptolemaus. The soldiers were sent out to seek the plant and found it in the place seen in the dream. Ptolemaus was healed by its use, as well as many others suffering from the same affection.
These dreams are not difficult to understand. Galen doubtless had a thought occur to him when awake that blood-letting might be good for his ailment. With this treatment in vogue at that time, it was a natural suggestion. The finger indicated is of no importance. It is extremely doubtful if a similar method would be practised today for a similar illness. We may believe that Galen got well in spite of the treatment, and not because of it. Likewise, it is probable that Alexander in thinking about his friend during the day noted a certain plant and wondered, if only for a moment, if it would be curative; the thought gave rise to the dream. Its curative value may be attributed to chance.
In noting remedies said to have been discovered in dreams we should be mindful of several things. One of these is that charlatans sometimes make use of the superstitious hold which dreams have on many people, and claim that they have been inspired in a dream as to how cures may be effected. Again, faith is very powerful. For example, when Cromwell, following the execution of Charles I, did away with the kingly practice of touching sick people in order to cure them of their ills, Greatrakes, an adventurer, let it be known that he had been appointed in a thrice repeated dream to cure the ailing by touching them; thousands flocked to him, and countless were cured or benefited by him. We have, also, the story of Elisha Perkins, of Norwich, Conn., who cured a great number of sick people, in this country and in Europe, with his metallic tractors, - pieces of metal about the size of a lead pencil which were applied to the bodies of the sick; it might be mentioned that many who sought to show the absurdity of the tractors, per se, in producing cures, as well as charlatans who wished to profit, cured hundreds by employing tractors made of wood, painted to resemble the tractors of Perkins. The story of Perkins is amusingly told by Dr. Oliver Wendell Holmes in his Medical Essays. In our own day we have any number of faith cures, not to mention countless proprietary medicines of little or no therapeutic value intrinsically, but which, judging by the testimonials, have, for a time at least, made their purchasers believe they were cured or on the road to recovery.
Suggestion, originating from within or from outside sources, is certainly of value in the treatment of many disorders. And it is on suggestion that the value of "faith cures" depends. Suggestion will not cure an organic disease, as cancer, though it does often cure functional maladies. Should a person have faith in the prophetic powers of dreams, a remedy said to have been discovered in dreams will benefit him for a time; if his faith is great and his trouble purely psychic, it may even cure him. The word cure is hardly appropriate in this connection however, since a very great percentage of those claiming to have been cured in a more or less spectacular way relapse into their old condition, just like many who, when filled with new-born optimism give out testimonials in praise of certain nostrums, find shortly afterwards that the medicine is doing them no good. It is possible, of course, that in an ordinary dream various plants may be seen, and that a person interested in the curative principles of plants may have his attention drawn to them. That chance may, at times, prove the plants to be useful is not at all mysterious.
Doubtless the belief in the ability of the dream to reveal cures was greatly strengthened when mesmerism, known also as animal magnetism, artificial somnambulism, and finally as hypnotism was at its height. The condition was regarded as identical with deep, natural sleep, and thus the prophecies, so-called, of hypnotized subjects were considered as possible to natural sleep. However, normal sleep and hypnotic sleep are not alike; further, a hypnotized person can reveal nothing outside the range of his or her own experience. If we were to credit the older authors, hypnotized persons were capable of all sorts of powers, as self-diagnosis, self-inspection - the ability to see all parts of the body, the power of prescribing for illness, to diagnose the ills of and prescribe for persons at a distance, etc. The Frau von U., magnetized by a clergyman, was said to have described the bones of the ear very minutely and accurately. Bertrand tells of sixty convulsive attacks of a dangerous nature which were foreseen and their time of occurrence and duration determined to a minute. As regards the Frau von U., she could only describe her ear bones from a previous reading about them. The convulsionists were able to predict so well because their convulsions were hysterical, and in no way the typical convulsions of true epilepsy.
A study of the history of animal magnetism is interesting, and profitable. It will show how far people will go in order to obtain notoriety, how it is possible for one to deceive himself and others, the great credulity of ignorant and educated, etc. One who is interested in the claims for animal magnetism will find in Du Prel's Philosophy of Mysticism a mass of positive, though questionable, data. The negative argument Jas-trow presents in his Fact and Fable in Psychology. For a good work analysing a case of artificial somnambulism the reader is referred to Flournoy's From India to the Planet Mars.
In passing, it might be mentioned that hypnotism is well understood today, and so no very remarkable claims are made for it. It has some usefulness in certain nervous disorders, but its place is being rapidly taken by more effective and safer methods.
 
Continue to: