This section is from the book "About Dreaming, Laughing And Blushing", by Arthur Mitchell. Also available from Amazon: About Dreaming, Laughing And Blushing.
(3) A relaxation of the muscular coats of the small arteries by which the capillaries become filled with blood, implying that the proper vasomotor centre is affected, is said by Darwin to be the explanation of the redness of blushing. In a broad general sense this is correct and sufficient. It is at least quite enough for my purpose. In what follows reference will often be made to the ordinary limitation of the redness to the face, neck, and ears, and to many other attendant phenomena. It is not necessary, however, for the purposes of this paper to examine minutely all that is involved, anatomically or in other related senses, in the quick suffusion of these regions with blood. There are differences of opinion - not in my opinion of vital importance - as to how the thing occurs and as to what precisely takes place, but I am only interested and concerned in the final event - in what happens as the outcome. To deal with these other matters would be a good and sufficient subject for a separate essay, but to do so here would draw attention from points on which I wish it to be concentrated.
(4) Of all the manifest bodily alterations from mental emotion blushing is perhaps the most surprising, and it may be regarded as the exclusive property of man. Darwin says that 'it would require an overwhelming amount of evidence to make us believe that any (of the lower) animals could blush.'
Many lovers of the lower animals believe that dogs feel and show a sense of shame, particularly of the shame that attends the detection of some fault in them by persons to whom they are attached; but, if they feel such a sense of shame, they show it in their own fashion, and this is never by anything which has an analogy to blushing. Nor is there any one special way of showing it common to all dogs. Other animals arc also believed to show this sense of shame, but nothing which is known in regard to any of them goes to weaken the opinion that man is the only animal that blushes. Perhaps there is room for questioning whether he is the only joker in nature and the only laugher, but it seems almost beyond question that he is the only blusher. This gives to the subject a special interest, though it does not really much affect the side of that interest which has occupied my thoughts.
(5) Bacon says: 'Shame causeth blushing, and casting down of the eyes,' and there is not much more than this to be said about the cause and character of blushing. It consists of a 'resort of blood to the face with a casting down of the eyes,' arising out of a sense of shame.
There remains, however, the need of knowing what is meant by the word shame. Locke says that it is 'an uneasiness of the mind upon the thought of having done something which is indecent, or something which will lessen the valued esteem that others have for us.' This seems to me to give the word nearly the whole meaning that is necessary in its relation to blushing.
Locke's definition makes the uneasiness of the mind to arise upon the thought of two different things. First it makes it arise upon the thought of anything that savours of indecency or indelicacy, which is being looked at or noticed by others, such for instance as an accidental exposure of the person. It will be observed that I make an addition here to Locke's definition. I make it essential or at least very important, that the thing be seen or observed by others. But I do not mean by this, that the thing shall be actually seen or even have actually occurred. If others look as if they saw some thing of this character, though it may not really exist, it is often sufficient to raise the sense of shame and the consequent blush. Nor is it necessary that the thing should be positively indecent. The apprehension that it may be considered indecent by those who are looking on is frequently sufficient. It is sometimes enough to call up the sense of shame and its expression in a blush, to be 'surprised into situations which merely attract the peculiar attention' of bystanders, though there is not even a suspicion of indelicacy in the situations. There is a 'quick apprehension that reputation and character are in danger,' and this is enough. A mere doubt or troubled thought as to how we are looking in the eyes of others may be sufficient to bring up the blush. The feeling of being looked at intently, with an apprehension as to what may be seen or thought, appears to be a steady element in 'the uneasiness of mind upon the thought of having done something which is indecent,' which Locke gives as the first part of his definition of that shame which raises the blush. I desire here to make another change or amplification of this part of Locke's definition. The word indecent is too crude. As used by him, it clearly includes unbecoming and indelicate, and is not confined to sexual indecency.
The blushing of this first kind is far more common than the blushing of the second kind to which I am now to refer, namely that caused by Locke's 'uneasiness of mind ' upon the thought of having done something with blameworthiness or guilt in it, that has been discovered by others who are present. Here again I make a change in Locke's definition. It is almost an essential that the discovery be made by others who are present, and whose good opinion may be lost or lessened - to this extent at least it is so, that thinking of a deed and its guiltiness when in solitude, and when the blame of others is not being expressed or in danger of being expressed, does not call up the blush of shame. The face of a girl, who suddenly becomes aware that a fault is being brought home to her in the presence of others, as for instance that she has been detected in a meanness or falsehood, is covered with a blush. She fears the open 'blame of evil,' and her cheeks redden with shame. Yet there may be no real guilt, as she may quite well know. The fear of being thought blameworthy is sufficient to raise a blush in persons of great sensibility, and they are numerous among the young. The blush of this kind does not always disclose a real transgression, though of course it does so with frequency.
 
Continue to: