It is thus quite certain that this blind and deaf girl blushed, and also that she did so from the same causes as make those girls blush who both see and hear. She had only the sense of touch to make her aware that others were present, for in her case smell, as well as sight and hearing, was defective, and she could not know what they were saying about her or that they were looking at her either intently or with curiosity, or with approbation or disapprobation. But in her mind she reached conclusions as to these matters, and she blushed, there being no real peculiarity in the cause of her blushing. The phenomena occurred in her as in other girls as the manifestation of an instinct often and not incorrectly called an inheritance.

Laura Bridgman died in 1889, but there is another American lady, Miss Helen Keller, to whom I have already referred, who is still alive and still young, and whose education has been carried far beyond that of Laura Bridgman. Regarding her also I have trustworthy information. Miss Sullivan, her distinguished governess, writes me that Miss Keller 'blushes much as other people do,' that 'she blushes at the thought of having made a mistake in answering a question, or under criticism, or when her feelings are hurt.' Miss Sullivan also says: 'She does not, I believe, blush increasingly as she grows K older': 'She is conscious of blushing, and sometimes rubs her face impatiently'; 'Her blushes spread over her neck and shoulders'; 'She said when I asked her, in reference to your letter, that she feels a blush tingling all over her.'

Mr. Hitz, the well-known secretary of the Volts Bureau, Washington City, writes me, that he received my letter asking information about Miss Keller's blushing while visiting her mother, who stated to him that 'she had never observed any difference whatever in Helen's blushing from that of her younger daughter and other normally endowed girls of like sensitive feeling.' Mrs. Keller also said to Mr. Hitz that Helen 'would certainly noticeably blush at the thought of having inadvertently committed a gaucherie, or that she had been detected in doing wrong.' Mrs. Keller could not tell 'at what age Miss Helen first blushed, but it was as early in life as most girls.' She thinks that 'as to her blushing increasing as she grows older, there is no evidence of it.' She says that Helen 'is aware when she blushes,' and that 'as regards the extent of her blushing, it is the same as that of any other young woman of innate refinement.' When being photographed she blushed at the idea that she was exposing her person too much to those present, but ceased to do so on being told by her governess who were present, and on being assured that all was right.

This is a most instructive and satisfying account of blushing, as it occursin the case of Miss Keller.

In all broad aspects, the blushing of Miss Keller is exactly the same as that of well educated and refined girls. She never saw other girls blush; she does not know by hearing or sight whether strangers or acquaintances are present; she does, however, in point of fact, know much more of whether persons are present and who they are, than can be easily explained; her blushing can have no relation to looks or words of disapproval, connected either with her appearance or conduct; yet she blushes just as girls do who see and hear, from the same causes, over the same parts of the body, and with the same experience of tingling. Blushing came to her as it came to them by inheritance, and it is in no sense or degree an operation of the will. It is a bodily manifestation of a mental state, and of that only, and it can neither be called up nor kept back by the will. What purpose such an expression of a mental emotion serves, we do not know. But this is only one of many such phenomena about which we know little or nothing. Whytt says - 'as little can we tell why shame should raise a heat and redness in

(20) Works on Pharmacology do not yield much information as to the flushing which attends the inhalation of nitrite of amyl. It is usually confined to the face, but it is said that sometimes nearly the whole trunk is affected. Speaking broadly, the locality and the extent of the nitrite flush correspond with those of blushing, though there is reason to think that the capillaries are somewhat more widely affected in the nitrite flush.

The inhalation of the nitrite quickens both the pulse and respiration; it has no narcotic effect; the sight is sometimes curiously influenced; it causes a feeling of fulness and throbbing in the head; and there is mental confusion and dizziness. I gather this from works on Pharmacology. I do not find that the occurrence of the mental confusion has received much attention, but it is accepted as a fact. The character and extent of the mental confusion do not appear to have been studied. Darwin calls it confusion and bewilderment, and tells of a woman who spoke of her condition as muddled. If we assume its existence, we then have the mental accompaniment of blushing presenting itself, when a bodily state occurs that resembles blushing, which is induced by the inhalation of a drug and not by a special state of the mind.

Darwin quotes Filehne as believing in a complete analogy between the action of nitrite of amyl and the mechanism of the natural blush (Kosmos, Jahrg. iii. 1879-80, p. 480), and also as thinking it not too rash to assume that the amyl-nitritc and the psychical cause of blushing attack the same point in the nervous system and produce the same effects (Pfluger's Archiv. Bd. ix. 1874, p. 491). This last, however, is not more than a guess at a possibility.

There can be no doubt as to the existence of a curious resemblance of the nitrite of amyl flush and the blush of shame, not only in the area affected and other physical characteristics, but also in the mental confusion and bewilderment which are produced. The blush is caused by one mental state and it then causes another. If we cause the flush by the administration of this drug, we appear to cause the same mental state which blushing produces. In other words, a special mental state gives rise to a special bodily state, which in its turn gives rise to another mental state, and if we cause that special bodily state by the nitrite, it appears to induce the same mental state as blushing does, in so far as mental confusion is concerned.