This section is from the book "About Dreaming, Laughing And Blushing", by Arthur Mitchell. Also available from Amazon: About Dreaming, Laughing And Blushing.
1 frequently saw James Mitchell when he was a grown man. I have seen him smile very often, and his smile was pleasant and in all respects like the smile of persons who could see and hear. Sometimes it was very broad and was attended with a chuckle, but I have no recollection of having ever heard him laugh sonorously. 1 remember, however, that he used his voice when angry, and that it was harsh and unpleasant. He died in 1860.
The next case of this kind which attracted wide attention was that of Laura Bridgman, who was born in New Hampshire, U.S.A., in 1829. She became completely blind and deaf in early infancy. The sense of smell was also nearly, if not completely, destroyed, and that of taste was perhaps blunted as a consequence of the defect in smell. Only touch remained in quite good order.
She was very successfully educated by Dr. S. G. Howe, a medical man of great ability. In successive reports of the Trustees of the Perkins Institution and Massachusetts Asylum for the Blind (1838, etc.), be gave an account of the progress and method of Laura's education. These reports, now difficult to find, have much value in consequence of their having been written by a man of such ability, who was in a position to give him full knowledge. He does not discuss separately or formally her dreaming, laughing, and blushing. The significance of these things in a person so conditioned was not then so fully seen as it is now, but casual allusions to them are numerous. He says that she was fond of fun and frolic, happy and playful, often smiling and laughing. When he speaks of her playing with other young persons, he says that 'her shrill laugh sounds the loudest of the group.' He writes of her as 'laughing and jumping about,' as 'screaming with delight,' and often as laughing 'heartily' or 'most heartily.' One of his remarks is: 'She laughs aloud and more naturally than most deaf persons [that is, persons only deaf, not both deaf and blind], and she is almost constantly doing so.' He says, however, that the sound of her laughter was not always agreeable. She used her voice curiously in naming persons - uttering a chuckle for one, a cluck for another, a nasal sound for a third, a guttural sound for a fourth, and so on, but no explanation of how this originated was found.
Mrs. Mary Swift Lamson, who was one of her teachers, wrote an account of the life and education of this deaf and blind girl. She speaks of Laura as 'convulsed with laughter,' and tells that 'she laughed aloud at the idea of a dog coming to school,' asking 'can a dog talk with fingers?' and adding, as she laughed heartily, 'a dog has no fingers.' We are told by Mrs. Lamson that 'one day she pretended that her doll was sick, put it to bed, placed a bottle of hot water at its feet, laughing all the time most heartily.' She speaks of Laura elsewhere as 'bursting into a loud laugh,' and says that she 'has a pleasant ringing laugh,' though at times she 'utters sounds that are disagreeable.'
Then further it is told by Lieber that when the contents of a letter from a friend, whom she greatly loved, were communicated to her, 'she laughed and clapped her hands, and the colour mounted to her cheeks.'
On these testimonies it may be accepted as certain that Laura Bridgman, though without the senses of sight, hearing, and smell, often laughed audibly, and still oftener smiled.
I have already written of Miss Bridgman's dreams, and further on I shall have to write of her blushing. I am obliged to bring up her case over and over again, but each fresh reference to it is from a new standpoint. So it is also with Miss Helen Keller, whose dreaming, and laughing, and blushing I have to discuss separately. It will be quite understood that I could not have said in one place all I have to say regarding these two unique eases of blindness and deafness. Miss Keller is also an American, and she is still alive and young. She is very intelligent, and her education has been so successful as to be almost beyond belief. I possess an excellent account of the methods adopted in teaching her and of the extent of her acquirements. But it gives no information regarding the matter with which I am at present concerned. I therefore applied to Mr. Hitz, of the Volta Bureau for the. Increase and Diffusion of Know-lodge relating to the Deaf (Washington City, U.S.A.), and he tells me that from frequent personal observation, and after consultation with Miss Sullivan, her distinguished teacher, he is able to say that Miss Keller laughs audibly and at times extremely heartily. He says that she is of a joyous temperament; that he has seen her, when bantering some one, shake with audible laughter, and place her hand on her mouth to prevent too much boisterousness; that, when she reads an amusing passage in a book, she smiles and occasionally gives an audible exclamation, akin to a suppressed outburst of laughter; and that frequently when by herself, spelling with her left hand into her right, she laughs aloud.
This last statement appears to furnish an exception to the common experience, already referred to, that we rarely laugh, in a proper and full sense, when we are quite alone.
Miss Keller's teacher. Miss Sullivan, writes me as follows regarding her pupil's laughter: 'Her laugh is low and pleasant. It lacks the ringing quality of a woman's voice, but has a peculiar and delightful merriment. Sometimes it is a low chuckle, sometimes a high but soft giggle. Her smile is very beautiful.'
Julia Brace, who was also completely deaf and blind, and who was educated up to a certain point at Hartford, Connecticut, has also been much written about, but these writings give little information as to her laughing. It is said, however, that 'her smile is gentle and sweet, though of rare occurrence,' and that' sometimes when apparently in deep thought she is observed to burst into laughter.'
Here again we have what appears to be an exception to the belief in the rarity of laughter in the case of persons who are alone. There may have been persons in the room with Julia when these ' bursts of laughter' occurred; but, unless she was aware of this, as she saw nothing and heard nothing, it would be difficult not to regard her as being quite alone.
 
Continue to: