This section is from the book "About Dreaming, Laughing And Blushing", by Arthur Mitchell. Also available from Amazon: About Dreaming, Laughing And Blushing.
(50) All the persons of whom I have been just speaking were entirely deprived both of sight and hearing, either from birth or from quite early infancy, but they all had good intellectual powers. Ludicrous ideas could be conveyed to them, though not through the eye or ear. They were liable like ordinary persons to the so-called tickling of the mind, and the point of interest here is, that this mental state was expressed in them by smiling or laughing, in the same way as in those who see and hear. Indeed the physical phenomena of laughter appear to be the same in them as in ordinary people. There are the same reiterated sounds 'produced by deep inspirations, followed by short interrupted spasmodic contractions of the chest and especially of the diaphragm,' the mouth opens and widens, the corners of it are drawn backward and upward, the upper lip is raised, and the orbicular muscles of the eyes are contracted. All these things they have never either seen or beard in others, and the phenomena cannot, therefore, in any sense be the result of imitation. They cannot have been learned. They are involuntary - are not directed by the Will, They seem to be innate, instinctive, or inherited. Why this violent and widespread muscular commotion should express a particular state of mind remains a mystery, yet not a greater mystery, as Darwin I think points out, than the wagging of its tail by a young pappy, when it is pleased, just as an old dog does, or the arching of its back by a kitten, when it is angry, just as an old cat does. The puppy and the kitten are too young to have learned these expressive actions from their elders. The instant arching of the back of a young cat that has been brought up without seeing a dog, when suddenly introduced to one, shows at its highest the wonderfulness of this instinctive or inherited expression of a mental state. Darwin and others have pointed out that the movements are Imbeciles, with their condition thus explained, laugh and smile freely - more or less freely according to the degree of mental weakness. Their smiling seems to express pleasure and happiness, but vanity and the love of approbation are at the root of much of their smiling and much of their happiness. The facial muscles are acted on in the same way as in the smiling of ordinary children. The sounds attending their laughter are distinctive, with differences in different individuals as might be expected. There is, however, the same reiteration as in the laughter of ordinary children, and the physical phenomena generally are essentially of the same character.
The pleasantness of the mental state, which causes the laughter of imbeciles, must often be associated with no definite ideas. They could not tell, and can scarcely know, why they laugh even when the laughter comes in bursts and seems to indicate much happiness. But there is not really much difference between imbeciles and ordinary children in this respect.
Grotesque and broadly ludicrous pictures thrown by a lantern on a screen excite peals of laughter in many imbeciles, but there are always some, who, for no reason that can be assigned, see nothing funny in the pictures and remain unaffected, neither smiling nor laughing. To some extent, however, this occurs with ordinary children, in a way which cannot be easily explained.
Imbeciles are not much given to mimicry among themselves, and seeing others mimic does not so readily provoke laughter as it does with ordinary children, and with savage races - Australians and Hottentots, for instance. These last, however, though their mental powers may be of a very low order, are in what to them is a normal state of health, and they cannot be said to labour under imbecility, which is a state of disease. The two conditions cannot be compared. There may be imbecile Bushmen, but Bushmen as a race are not imbeciles.
Tickling of the armpits or soles of the feet causes imbecile children to laugh, but the general opinion is that they are not so readily tickled as ordinary children, and it is almost certain that, when they reach manhood or womanhood, they are much less easily tickled than ordinary people.
(52) The tickling that causes laughter is a tickling of the skin. A man may in a sense be said to live between his skin and his mucous membrane, and it seems possible that, when certain parts of his inner skin or mucous membrane are acted on in a way more or less resembling what we know as tickling, special states of mind may be induced, which differ greatly from the state held to be consequent on tickling certain parts of the outer skin - as greatly, perhaps, as sadness differs from merriment. For example, it is possible that hardened feculent masses in the large intestine may act on the mucous membrane in a way somewhat analogous to tickling, with mental depression as the result. Then it is possible that a worm in the oesophagus may, in consequence of something like tickling, give rise to maniacal excitement, as in that or in some other way it is alleged to have done. I do not go further than indicate these as possibilities. In Dr. Burn-Murdoch's case, given G by Wyllie in his Disorders of Speech, very marked effects on the mind are not unfairly attributed to, or at least connected with, a large round worm somewhere in the intestine. A child four years old became noisy, unmanageable, and destructive, grimacing and whistling loudly, and using very foul language. Under treatment this child passed a round worm ten inches long, and a rapid improvement of all the symptoms then took place. Professor Wyllie finds the interest of the ease in its showing how the mental functions may be disturbed by an irritation of the intestine acting reflexly on the brain. My comment is that it is possible to hold this irritation as comparable to tickling. If it is comparable, then the number of such comparable irritations may be great, and the effects produced by them various.
(53) When nitrons oxide or laughing-gas is respired in a suitable quantity and manner it causes laughter. The physical phenomena of this laughter are the same as those which attend laughter either from tickling or from a merry state of mind, unless perhaps they arc differentiated by the more or less complete absence of anything that can be called smiling. Neither Davy1 nor any other writer on the subject, so far as I am aware, makes the special commotion of the facial muscles, which constitutes a smile, to be a result of breathing the gas. But the references to voiced laughter, as distinguished from smiling, are abundant. Indeed the familiar name of the gas is laughing-gas. I have frequently seen nitrous oxide given as Davy gave it, and cannot remember that I ever saw the commotion of the facial muscles, which constitutes smiling; but it was not looked for, and it may have been present. If it is steadily absent from the voiced laughter caused by this drug, it would be a point of much interest. The phenomena of voiced laughter are present, but perhaps the muscular commotion is greater, and it may extend much beyond the muscles of respiration. There is more stamping, dancing, running about, and vociferating. Davy, in reference to his own experiences, speaks of an ' irresistible propensity to action'; he says, 'sometimes I manifested my pleasure by stamping or laughing only - at other times by dancing round the room and vociferating'; he speaks of a disposition to muscular movement and to merriment; on one occasion he says that he 'made strides across the room, and continued for some minutes much exhilarated,' and on another occasion that he: had a great disposition to laugh ' and that he 'experienced pleasure by laughing and stamping.'
 
Continue to: