WE have so far studied the effects, in certain cases, of the repression of past experiences, and of their recall to memory and their reconnection with the main stream of mental life; and also the methods by which these recalls from the supposed dead and buried past are obtained.

We will now look further into the general nature of these buried experiences.

We can divide them, roughly, into two classes:

(1) memories of events, the unpleasantness of which gives a motive for forgetting them; and

(2) impulses and desires which have conflicted with other desires incompatible with them, and which have been repressed for the sake of mental peace, or the repression of which has conduced to mental efficiency.

The two classes, however, are not entirely separated, for evidently a desire which leads to constant conflict and disappointment, and, so, to unpleasant feeling, will itself be apt to take on a tinge of associated unpleasantness; the getting rid of the conflict is a means of getting rid of unhappiness, or at least of one element of it.

It is one of the main tenets of Freudian psychology that the period of childhood is of special importance in its unconscious influence upon later life, and we have already considered several cases in which intense emotional experiences of childhood have been repressed. It is held that, to a large extent, the unconscious impulses are the remnants of desires and impulses repressed in childhood. The "filling" of the unconscious with such repressed impulses is supposed to take place especially in childhood, because the natural tendencies of children are held to be so bad from a social point of view that training is largely directed towards repressing such tendencies. One of Freud's most distinguished followers states that "without social pressure the individual would probably remain a selfish, jealous, impulsive, aggressive, dirty, immodest, cruel, egocentric and conceited animal, inconsiderate of the needs of others, and unmindful of the complicated social and ethical standards that go to make a civilised society."*

Repression in Infancy.

* Ernest Jones, Papers on Psycho-Analysis, p. 124.

This statement is not lacking in vigour; but it gives no hint of the many natural good impulses of the child. The special characteristic of the young child is not selfishness, but impulsiveness. A mere infant may be as unselfish in his impulse as an adult, with a beautiful abandon indeed which is rare in later life. However, it is undoubtedly true that the child, in the face of social pressure, must repress many strong impulses, and these, it is supposed, become buried in the unconscious.

Freud lays great stress upon the repression of sex impulses in early childhood; he believes that sex impulses and interests begin at a much earlier age than has usually been supposed. No doubt there is evidence that in certain cases this is so. But it is by no means clear that in the majority of children the interest in matters of sex, in the strict and narrow sense of the term, is any greater than their interest in a score of the other wonderful things of this world, in which all is to them so novel, unless and until the interest in sex is stimulated by an attitude of secrecy on the part of adults. It is important to recall however in fairness to Freud, that, as already hinted,he uses the word sex in a much wider sense than is usual. Especially is this the case in reference to the sex life of very young children. In them, according to Freud, there appear, not, of course, the actual impulses towards reproduction, but what he calls partial impulses of sex, such as the craving for the enjoyment of sucking, the delight in kissing and anal excitation, the impulses to cause or suffer pain (sadism and masochism). These become unified only later with the sex impulses proper.

Childhood and Sex.

Even with this very disputable modification of the term sex I am personally far from being convinced that even these partial impulses attain any great strength in the majority of children.

Nor does the fact that various impulses become later intimately associated with sex seem to me to prove that they are in any real sense sexual in their early appearance. Freud's view, indeed, seems to involve as a logical consequence that the senses of touch and smell are in essence sexual.

In any case it seems unnecessary to stress the significance of sex in early childhood, for the violent outburst of the sex instinct at adolescence and young manhood and womanhood will evidently afford good material and many occasions for repressions, and we have clear indications that this period may be of profound influence in the mental life not only of abnormal but of normal individuals.

True, the evidence of the ill-effects of repression is based largely on the study of abnormal cases; and we have no evidence that either in these cases or in the case of more normal individuals a more lax attitude towards the moral code would have led to a saner mental life. The general trend of the new psychology, indeed, is in favour of calm rational control, of bringing all impulses within the unifying control of one aim or ideal. But it is also in favour of bringing to consciousness the vague and half-repressed impulses due to the great instincts. And the evils following on the emotional sex experiences of youth are far more likely to be due to the attempt at repressing from consciousness the awakening emotions of sex, and especially to the worry and anxiety due to ignorance about the beginnings of physiological sex processes, than to conscious control of sex under the influence of a moral ideal.

There are grave dangers, however, in some of the unguarded assertions made on the question of sex repression. I recently heard a distinguished psycho-therapist say, to a large audience, "You cannot repress a great instinct without its taking its revenge upon you."