This section is from the book "Dreams And The Unconscious: An Introduction To The Study Of Psycho-Analysis", by Charles Wilfred Valentine. Also available from Amazon: Dreams and the Unconscious: An Introduction to the Study of Psycho-Ananlysis.
Or we may suppose that without any revival of an emotion, or even of any decided feeling, the critical word, A, tends to call up a repressed idea or feeling, B, which is associated with it; but the repression continues to act, a "resistance" is set up - a resistance not deliberate like that in the first test described above, though once, perhaps, it was. A likely result, of this resistance is that a third word, C, is called up, a side association of B or possibly a symbolic representation of B, as sometimes actually happens in these tests. Such a process is quite familiar to normal psychology, which is already acquainted with occurrences in which a series of associations, A - B - C, is finally contracted so that the intermediate B drops out, and the idea of the following C is recalled without the recall of B. It is, we may suppose, a sort of short-circuiting taking place in the brain processes. Hence, we may have in everyday life frequent cases like the following. We read some name or hear some place or object mentioned, and we experience at once a marked feeling of pleasure (or displeasure). We cannot understand why the name should cause us such a feeling of pleasure; we feel a "gap" in the mind; and, then, after an interval we remember the important link, the event which originally caused a similar feeling of pleasure, and with which the name is perhaps only remotely associated. Yet the hearing of the name was enough to rouse the memory of the event to a kind of sub-conscious activity, and this was enough to produce the feeling; or perhaps the indirect linking of the name through the main original experience (now forgotten) to the original pleasant feeling was enough to tinge the name with the feeling tone of the pleasing experience, and so to arouse the pleasure directly when the name was heard.
The Rousing of Repressed Memories.
Whichever of these is the truer description, we have, in such examples as these, a common everyday example of the arousal of a feeling by a word only indirectly associated with that feeling in past experience, and when the main ideas connected with that past experience are not present in consciousness. In other words, we have a displacement of feeling or "affect" which the Freudians emphasise as a characteristic process in the unconscious, and which is similar to that transference of feeling from the real object to a symbol in dreams, We see then how a side association may arouse a disturbing emotion in the word test, and how this may cause hesitation or delay, and at times that feeling of a "gap" or "block" or something missing, which may be experienced by the subject undergoing the test.
This example of everyday occurrence throws light, not only on the delayed reactions in the word test experiments, but on the cases of abnormal emotionality or excessive feeling produced by relatively small causes. In the case of my friend who had occasional paroxysms of unreasonable fear (described in Chapter II (Mental Conflict And Repression)), the word test was used. One phrase read to the subject - "take care"- caused one of these intense emotions of fear. There was a prolonged delay in response; and then the subject said that the words suggested taking care of health, and later, anxieties in youth about health and its relation to certain matters of sex. This was one of the clues which led us to suppose that the origin of the unreasoning fears lay in the excessive anxieties of youth about sex. In this not very serious case the probable originating cause was readily recalled. In more serious cases, when the original cause is forgotten, we must suppose that an associated idea, through its connection with the buried memory, is able to rouse the emotion; or, perhaps, an emotion which has been mildly aroused may, in its turn, rouse to subconscious activity buried memories which again re-act upon the emotion with added violence.
Transference of Feeling.
McDougall's theory as to the physiology of the matter, is that, through being relatively isolated, the complex works up more energy, the emotion centre working on the main brain processes correlated with the repressed memories, these again rousing to still greater activity the emotion centre, and so on. Normally, there would be a "drainage of energy" from the repressed-idea-brain-process to those processes correlated with ideas connected with it. The repression of the idea, however, results in its isolation.
There are difficulties about this drainage theory; but I think we may apprehend the matter in a way which makes the psychological aspect more comprehensible by considering again some facts of normal mental life. Suppose we find out a surprising fact about a friend, something which indicates disloyalty. We are, at first, perhaps, much angered. Then our mind begins to turn to other ideas about him, which show his loyalty at other times. The new fact is indisputable, and we cannot help its influencing us; better memories of our friend may at first seem to accentuate the disloyalty by force of contrast, but the emotion of anger is not usually so strong when the new fact is seen in due proportion to other ideas about our friend, i.e. when the older memories have their due influence - perhaps McDougall would say when there has been time for "drainage" of energy to take place. The isolated idea meant intense emotion; when forming only one item in a whole, it means less intense emotion. It should be noted that it is not necessary that the later ideas should prove the new fact incredible; we may still find it incontrovertible that on one occasion the friend was disloyal. It is evident, however, that the emotion will be still further reduced in intensity in those cases in which the later ideas do actually modify the first - if, for example, the remembrance of what our friend has been and done in the past makes us see the new act in a new light, and regard it as probably explicable by some fact not yet known to us. This suggests to us how things work in many of the cases in which a recovery of memory means recovery of mental health. In the recall of the worries about sex in boyhood a man may realise that they were exaggerated and foolish; the "complex" causing the trouble, which kept the emotion of fear in a highly sensitive and unstable condition, may be actually destroyed, when the idea on which it was based is seen to be false and groundless. Thus we see that some of the cures which appear at first extraordinary are not quite so incomprehensible in the light of orthodox psychology.
The Isolation of Emotion.
One word of caution may be added in reference to the word test. As already suggested, prolonged reactions need not necessarily indicate some buried complex which needs resurrecting, and for the doctor to suggest possible associations to his patient (either deliberately or indirectly, e.g. by his theories being known to his patient) is firstly to vitiate the reliability of the line of associations, and, secondly, to run the risk of suggesting sources of trouble that did not previously exist. Finally, there are various other ways besides that of the prolonged reaction by which a buried complex may reveal itself in the tests, as, for example, by the mere repetition of the stimulus word.
Mention must be made of a most interesting phenomenon, which occurs in many cases in which a patient is submitted to psycho-analysis. When some repressed emotional experience is revived and its original causes laid bare, the feeling is often transferred from its former object to the person analysing the patient; thus a hopeless passion for a friend of long ago, when brought to the surface again, issues in a warm affection for the physician; or the forgotten hatred of another may result in anger towards the physician. It is as though the feeling concerned, in the throes of its struggle for liberty, must first find some new object to which it can attach itself, albeit more lightly. This new attachment may then be "explained away" again by the physician leaving the patient free from the tyranny of his emotion.
Note on the Influence of Suggestion.
The view has been held that the supposed cures by release of repression and by re-association and re-education are really only elaborate cases of cures by suggestion. The enormous power of suggestion is now clearly established. As Dr. Rivers points out, among savages it is capable of producing death. Undoubtedly suggestion plays an important part in many cures. But it is noteworthy that even those neo-Freudians who confessedly make much use of suggestion, are convinced that suggestion is not the sole, or the chief, factor in most of their cures. In some cases cured only after the release of repressed memories, suggestion has been persistently tried before without success. Dr. Rivers points out that the proportion of cures by the psycho-analytic method in the army was greater among officers than among the rank and file, though the latter are undoubtedly more suggestible. It might, perhaps, be argued that because of their greater ability to understand the rationale of the method of cure, the officers would bo more apt to believe that a cure by this method was possible, and, therefore, that such a rational suggestion would have much more weight with them than the usual type of suggestion.
In this matter, however, great weight must be attached to the judgment of the medical men who, with this very question in mind, have constantly had the process of cure actually under observation. It must be admitted that at present it is impossible absolutely to disprove the assertion that many of the cures are largely due to suggestion; but in some cases a cure seems to have followed the revival of repressed memories when there were no grounds for supposing that suggestion could be at work, when, for example, the patient did not know that the recall had anything to do with a method of cure.*
* Cf. the case described by Dr. Wm. Brown in Psychology and Psychotherapy, pp. 21, 22. On the general question see E. Jones, Papers in Psycho-Analysis, ch. xviii., and W. H. R. Rivers, Instinct and the Unconscious, p. 201.
 
Continue to: